| Platinum | South Bend Chocolate Company |
| Platinum | Vanilla Bean |
| Gold | Paddy Shack |
| Silver | Cold Stone Creamery |
| Silver | The Chief Granger |
| Bronze | Bonnie Doon Drive-In |
| Top Pick | La Rosita |
| Top Pick | Ritters Frozen Custard |
| Top Pick | Urban Swirl |
| Top Pick | Whistle Stop Ice Cream |