| Platinum | Nedderman's Steak Place |
| Gold | Jim's Smokin' Cafe |
| Silver | Howard Park Public House |
| Bronze | Howard Park Public House |
| Top Pick | Copper Rock Steakhouse South Bend |
| Top Pick | Hestons |
| Top Pick | Logan's Roadhouse |
| Top Pick | LongHorn Steakhouse |
| Top Pick | Maxi's Food and Spirits Barn |
| Top Pick | Texas Roadhouse |