| Platinum | Allie's Cafe |
| Gold | Peggs |
| Silver | Studebagels |
| Bronze | Mishawaka Public House |
| Top Pick | Bill's Place Family Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Evil Czech Brewery |
| Top Pick | Howard Park Public House |
| Top Pick | The Early Bird Eatery |
| Top Pick | Uptown Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Weiss Gast Haus |