| Platinum | Hall's Kitchen |
| Gold | Barnaby's |
| Silver | Luigi's Pizza |
| Bronze | Rocco's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Bruno's Pizza Downtown |
| Top Pick | Cosimo & Susie's A Bit-Italy |
| Top Pick | Mimmos Pizza |
| Top Pick | Pasquale Rulli Pizza |
| Top Pick | Starlite Pizza and Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Volcano Restaurant |