| Platinum | Under The Sea Mermaids Pearls |
| Gold | The Portage Collective |
| Silver | Treasureology |
| Bronze | Chickadees Gift Shop |
| Top Pick | Greene Town Market |
| Top Pick | Indiana Rug Co |
| Top Pick | Olde District 5 |
| Top Pick | Take Care, South Bend |
| Top Pick | The Botany Shop |
| Top Pick | Thymeless Boutique |