| Platinum | Eby's Old Fashion Meat Market |
| Gold | DC Meats |
| Silver | Old Hoosier Meats |
| Bronze | Martins Butcher Shop- Wakarusa |
| Top Pick | Bamber Superette |
| Top Pick | Fresh Thyme Farmers Market- Mishawaka, IN |
| Top Pick | Jaworski's Market |
| Top Pick | Martin's Super Markets |
| Top Pick | St. Clair's Butcher Shop |