| Platinum | Papa Vino's |
| Gold | Olive Garden |
| Silver | Carmela's |
| Bronze | Macri's Italian Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Antonio's |
| Top Pick | Cosimo & Susie's A Bit-Italy |
| Top Pick | Howard Park Public House |
| Top Pick | Mishawaka Public House |
| Top Pick | South Bend Public House |
| Top Pick | Starlite Pizza and Restaurant |