| Platinum | Karma Cakes by Heidi |
| Platinum | Macris |
| Gold | West End Bakery |
| Silver | Mom's Kieflies |
| Bronze | Ragamuffin |
| Top Pick | Chips & Doodles |
| Top Pick | Grateful Pie Company |
| Top Pick | Honey's Bakery Mg |
| Top Pick | The South Bend Challah Company |
| Top Pick | Whole Foods Market Mishawaka |